now in 2006, they released a 2-disc version of the soundtrack. disc one was still the same, but disc two is where is started to get interesting. the majority of the disc are highly forgettable demo versions of many of the songs (when you hear them you can tell why they went the way they did, but it's still cool to hear the evolution of the songs). but the first 5 tracks of the second disc were covers by popular artists. it has marilyn manson doing this is halloween, fiona apple doing sally's song, fall out boy doing what's this?, she wants revenge doing kidnap the sandy claws, and final panic at the disco (also) doing this is halloween. now that right there was the springboard for nightmare revisited.
nightmare revisited is a compilation cover album. with lots of different bands and artists of all sorts of sounds and background coming together to pay tribute to something that (i'm guessing) they all love. the only thing that is truly original on here (and i have great respect for this) is the original opening and closing. it's been a little while since i've watched the movie so i can't remember if they changed it there (though i think they did), but the narrator at the beginning and the end was eventually re-recorded by patrick stewart and as much as i love that man's voice, it's just not right in my book (but that's pretty much what bruce campbell did on dead next door). so it really is great that they have put that on here. although i can't remember the original narrator's name (and i can't find it on imdb).
it really is a bit astounding how many people they pulled in for this, the only one that had been heard before (to the best of my knowledge) was the manson cover of this is halloween. but for bands you should have heard of before, you have korn covering kidnap the sandy claws (which if you can imagine korn covering it, that is what it sounds like and it's awesome), devotchka performing the opening overture (and i hope that people still remember devotchka from little miss sunshine), amy lee singing sally's song (as much as i don't care for her typically, she does really well with this and i like her version more than fiona's). there is also rise against covering making christmas and (as a bonus track) tiger army doing oogie boogie's song (while it's fun i still like the other version that is on this disc more). all american rejects also have a cover of jack's lament, but i didn't really care for it. it's not a bad song, but the singer's voice bothers me a little. finally, for the shit you should know (at least anyone who knows me will know him) rjd2 doing such a crazy bad ass version of the christmas eve montage. rjd2 was one of the major deciding factors for me to buy this album.
now for the stuff that you've probably never heard of, but should you check this disc out, it will make you want to check out more of them. the town meeting song being covered by the polyphonic spree (the only reason i even knew they is because of work that they have done with rjd2) is transformed into this monumentally epic 9:50 laid back chillfest. others include nabbed by the yoshida brothers (a japanese duo that combines classic japanese instrumentation with western sound configurations [they also have a song on the animation show one short mt. head]). the (in my opinion) better version of oogie boogie's song is by rodrigo y gabriella and the song sounds like you might think it would by their name. it doesn't have any of the lyrics in it, but it's primarily played acoustically and is also sped up maybe a quarter or half beat (but it might just sound like that to me). also noteworthy are amiina's doctor finkelstein/ in the forest, vitamin string quartet's jack and sally montage, datarock's to the rescue (super crazy disco bad-ass-ed-ness), and shiny toy guns' finale/reprise.
while i didn't really hate anything on this disc, there are a few tracks that i just don't care for as much as others. i've already mentioned the all american rejects and tiger army songs that i don't really like. of the remaining four tracks i have yet to mention, two of them i could give or take. flyleaf's what's this? and poor jack by plain white t's. neither of them are bad songs, but sometime i feel like listening to them more than i do other times. sparklehorse's jack's obsession is just too toned down and laid back. this is a song of passion and excitement, but here the singer just sounds like he couldn't give a shit. plus (again) the dude's voice just grates on me. lastly, the album leaf covering the end titles. now this one is not bad or even skip worthy. it just isn't especially memorable. it's actually a very good song, but still it makes no impact.
on the whole, this is worth checking out even if you don't dig nightmare but still dig good music. this album will more than likely turn you on to a bunch of music you never knew existed. but then again, anything i write about in here, you out there should be checking out. so go, do it.